Beitashour official, and Will Johnson! Woof!
Over a week after it was first reported, TFC finally got all the details figured out and confirmed that they have indeed signed Steven Beitashour, sending a draft pick to Vancouver as compensation (their second highest 2016 second round superdraft pick (currently their own, 29th overall, but who knows what other picks might come their way, for example their highest is currently the one we got from Philadelphia for Warren Creavalle which we then gave to Seattle for Eriq Zavaleta, say we do a deal with Colorado for their 2nd round pick, that would then be the highest and go to Seattle, the Seattle one would then be the second highest and go to Vancouver, and TFC would then be left with the 3rd highest, their own, that’s currently with Vancouver. MLS!).
A good pickup, presumably his salary will be more or less the same as last season, if so roughly 200k but who knows really and he should fit very well with what Greg Vanney wants from his full backs, to be good going forward while still being defensively competent. Add him to Drew Moor and Justin Morrow and that’s 3/4 of the first choice defence sorted. Very nice, weaknesses targeted and improved.
Then the interminable ‘who’s Will Johnson going to sign for?’ saga came to an end and what do you know, he’s coming to Toronto too! Exciting news, of the 3 players brought in so far, he’s definitely the best, but at the same time probably the most unnecessary. I’m having a hard time seeing exactly how this all fits together, both on the pitch and on the cap balance sheet.
On the pitch, it’s going to be very interesting to see just how Johnson fits in alongside Michael Bradley. Can they work together as a double pivot, the 2 of a 4-2-3-1? Would they work in a diamond midfield, with a DM behind them, a number 10 ahead and the full backs and a roaming Sebastian Giovinco charged with providing the width? There’s a few ways you could look at it and think ‘that might work’ but there’s obvious drawbacks to them all as well, not least my lack of faith in Greg Vanney’s ability to get Bradley to stick to a plan. He’s a very similar player to Bradley, not really a defensive midfielder, not an attacking one, nor a proper wide player. He’s a good box to box midfielder, but then so’s Bradley, how TFC find a place for both of them will be a huge test (my first choice would be to trade Bradley, but alas, that’s not happening). After a couple of smart signings that fill obvious needs and solve obvious problems, this feels like a bit of a good old TFC signing. He’s talented, sure, and within the Venn Diagram of MLS and Canada, probably the biggest name in the overlap (Cyle Larin perhaps?), but where exactly does he fit? What problem is he solving? Rather than solving a problem, in a way he creates a new one (a good one, but a problem all the same). Someone’s probably going to have to go to make way for him (Portland had a similar problem, the solution they eventually came up with was that Johnson was the one to go, that’s when everything fell into place and via a bit of a luck in a penalty shootout, the rest is history, anyway best not to think too hard about that).
Another problem is with the salary cap. These 3 signings are all expensive and though we’ll never know exact numbers, they’ll probably add somewhere between 800 and 900k to the payroll. And we still have to sign a goalie, and then depending on just how far down the wishlist you go maybe some new DM, maybe a true winger. Obviously some salary was shed with the release of Bendik, Findley and Jackson, and Ahmed Kantari is a preposterously obvious option for the one buyout allowed each year, but there’s going to have to be other moves to make all this make sense. Previously we’ve seen Laba and Ol’ Gil sacrificed to make room, who knows who’ll go this year.
My fervent hope is that Damien Perquis will also somehow be released, his salary is way too high for someone people are talking about as ‘should be a decent number 2 centre back with better people around him’. An answer to the cap problem, and also the ‘how does everyone fit into this midfield’ question is of course Benoit Cheyrou, that one would hurt.
There was talk that both Perquis and Cheyrou had a lot of allocation money spent to bring their cap hit down, perhaps their actual salary is enough that they fit into the range where TAM (some of which went to Portland in the Johnson deal) can be used instead, thus freeing up the general allocation money and regular cap space for some of these new expensive toys. While that may be a convenient solution, if the answer to ‘what did TFC do with their fancy new money?’ is in anyway ‘Damien Perquis’ then they’d need to be fully stripped of the ‘off season champions’ title people are hastily bestowing on them again (maybe we wait to see what everyone else does first? Just a thought). Anyway, as always TFC are interesting.
Despite my concerns about just how these questions get answered, this has been a remarkably good week for TFC. 3 very good players, with MLS experience. 2 of them obvious upgrades in positions of obvious need, and as for the other one, figuring out how to fit another talented player in is a very good problem for a coach to have. Exactly how they figure out the cap puzzle before March and the midfield puzzle once the season starts will be very interesting to watch, It’s going to take some good wonking and good coaching, and I’m not entirely convinced either Bezbatchenko or Vanney are up to their respective tasks, but you really can’t complain about the trades made so far.
December 18, 2015
An exciting week for TFC. I like these signings, and that they are all experienced players who are not too old. We have lots of youth players starting to develop, but these guys add some decent heft to the squad if they are really going to push for a title.
I kind of liked when Bradley played as a No 10 this season, so I would like to see a 4-3-2-1, with Jozy up front, Bradley in the middle, and Giovinco and Osorio on the wings. Then Cheyrou and Johnson as DMs. I wonder how that would work. But man, this is starting to be a pretty stacked squad! (famous last words)
I worry about the coach though. I think their next priorities should be a goalkeeper and then get a real coach, even if they said they would keep faith in Vanney. But why, when he hasn’t earned it? There won’t be many opportunities to get this many quality players on the team at the same time – why waste their chance with an unproven coach? I guess that’s an argument for another day.
Anyway for now I think we can be very happy with these defensive improvements. An early Xmas present I suppose!
December 19, 2015
agree with the 4-2-3-1 as you describe it there if we start the season with what we have now as the midfield options, which I’m not convinced about.
I’d love a new improved coach before the season starts, but am more and more resigned to the idea that vanney will get to start the season. with the new improved defence (presuming we get a goalie) and extra talent in midfield, there’s really no excuse for him (though of course it was presumed that the arrival of perquis had fixed the defence last year as well, and that wasn’t held against Vanney) so hopefully the leash is short. hopefully he figures it out and we do well, but next best scenario is it goes horribly wrong and we can him before the summer trandfer window.
December 19, 2015
Wait a minute isn’t the 4-3-2-1 a tighter, give it to Bradley and let him run with it, while the 4-2-3-1 stresses defending midfielders and trying to link to the attackers?
December 19, 2015
Remember way back when Chelsea had Lampard, Makelele, Essien, Cole AND Robben and they went out signed Ballack. Do you remember like everyone on my beer league team, how you were shocked by the sheer accrual of talent and how the Ballack thing was going to work? Well this isn’t like that, but it has elements of that.
So Johnson is going to be better than $5.5 million per year cheaper than Bradley. Mmmm…this will make for an interesting locker-room.
Beitashour, together with Moor will make for a pretty deep backfield.
December 19, 2015
thunk there’s still questions to the defence, but they’re acceptable questions, the sort any mls team is naturally going to have to have so fair enough really.
at least that chelsea midfield you refer to had a good variety of players, a proper dm, a winger. problem for tfc is that there’s a lot of similarity, not much specialisation. no obvious dm, no obvious width. (osorio and delgado I guess, but the full backs are going to have to provide a lot of it, which may cause problems of course, or giovinco, but can/should he be put in a bit of a stricter position for the sake of formational coherence?)