Toronto FC vs Montreal Impact: Voyageurs Cup 2 – Time For TFC To Go For It

Montreal Impact as the Manic

Montreal Impact as the Manic

Well Sunday was loads and loads of fun wasn’t it?  Happy homecoming everyone, now here’s a dispiriting loss for you as a welcome back present.   But we have to look forward; mostly because looking back is just too depressing.  Tonight TFC host the cheesemakers in the home leg of their round of the Voyageurs Cup (7:30pm, SportsnetOne) under the intimidating Redwall of BMO and given the suddenly cooling temperatures, in front of maybe 15,000 fans (I’m likely being generous) to see if Toronto FC can put forth a more consistent effort and move forward in the tournament.

Last week’s game was a dull affair, and frustrating to watch as a TFC fan given the odd lineup that Greg Vanney put out on the pitch – hardly any of the first team, hardly any Canadian kids – that had no ideas going forward in the final third.  It was a struggle to watch and I still find myself a week later trying to figure out what was happening, other than not much effort for much of the game.  Of course they’re only down the one goal (which is shocking and highlights the Impact’s poor form right now) so there is a huge opportunity for TFC to win this game.

The big question is of course, do they even want to?  I’m sure the players want to win – they’re professional athletes and this is what they do – but does the club really care about this game or the tournament itself?  You’d be hard-pressed to find much in the way of promotion; certainly not anything that approaches the over the top promotion that say the next game against Columbus (Trillium Cup baby!), or the friendly against Man City or honestly almost any other game will bring.  After Sunday’s game the monster car announcer guy didn’t even give us a ‘Fans! See you Wednesday night as your Toronto FC take on the Montreal Impact’ – it barely seems to rate a mention.  So how do the team and the fans get themselves hyped up for this game if the club itself can’t be bothered?

So what kind of line up will Vanney put out there tonight?  It’s likely going to be a lot like last week with few of the starters taking to the pitch and more of the bench/TFCII kids getting a run out.  There’s been talk that Sebastian Giovinco will play tonight; although little to no mention of the other starters and whether or not they’ll even feature at all.  It’s fairly obvious that a combination of not really caring about this competition and wanting to immediately bounce back in league games after the poor effort and loss from Sunday will impact Vanney’s decision.  With their game against one of the league leaders – and on the road no less – the New England Revolution this Saturday, it is unlikely that he will elect to field that strong of a team as their only focus this year is the league. And while of course MLS is important and yes I want this team to make the playoffs, the Voyageurs Cup is important too; no really it is and I wish they’d stop telling us otherwise.

My views on this are fairly apparent but I’ll say it again – there is little to no harm in trying to win the Voyageurs Cup this year – it is two extra games this August if you make the final. Two.  There’s no CCL to play in until next season when presumably (hopefully) you have a team of slightly better players that have been together for awhile and can handle the rigors (using that term lightly) of a few extra games that may propel them forward into competition against some pretty good teams and onto the world stage.  If the Trillium Cup is a thing that is to be highlighted, then why the hell wouldn’t you want to win this and move forward?  Players like to play and they like to win; why would you basically tell them ‘don’t bother to try in these games’?

As for the fans – yes, there is a constant core group (myself included) that truly love the Voyageurs Cup – we look forward to this every year with great anticipation.  As for those new fans that the club so desperately wants to fill the seats (only 8,400 more to convince!)?  Why would you turn away from something that is so easy to promote?  This is a Canadian club competition (ooh, potential sponsor klaxon), we usually play against one of our biggest rivals so built in atmosphere; why wouldn’t you promote the hell out of this?  Why treat it as an afterthought?   So don’t tell me the fans don’t care; they’ve been told to not care; just like the players.  *end rant*

As for Montreal?  Well they’re still trying to prove that they’re more than just a team that lucked into the CCL final and now languishes at the bottom of the MLS ladder.  They certainly have weapons at their disposal (those Jack, Mac and Ernie guys are deadly!), Dominic Oduro seems to be in one of his scoring/try hard years, Ignacio Piatti is dangerous, the always irritating Kenny Cooper and so on.  Not to mention their captain, Canadian Patrice Bernier who is very much on board with the importance of the Voyageurs Cup – so hey, they’re motivated and want to win.  This is going to end badly isn’t it?

There is every reason to think that TFC can win this game.  They’ve got the talent to win, but is there the will? Come on guys, it’s really not a bad thing to win this – all we ask is that you try.

Author: Kristin Knowles

Raised on basketball and baseball, Kristin soon saw the error of her ways when enrolled in a local football league as a child. Geography dictated she choose TFC as her team and ten years later she's still yet to flee the city. Cynically optimistic, she now channels her inner hooligan by singing random pop songs and making poor puns in the stands. May contain adult content. Find me on the internet machine @kzknowles

Share This Post On


  1. yeah, hopefully they go for it here, rest players in new england if necessary, they’re not going to win that anyway and that way you can avoid the turf at gillette stadium. Hopefully there’ll be pressure from above to not shit the bed again at home given they need to keep fans onside.

    Guess it’ll probably come down to what they think fans will pay the most attention to, a home game in the voyageurs cup or an away league game. or maybe that should be least attention. what type of defeat would be easiest to get away with?

    Post a Reply
    • You’d hope that they want to get a win at home as soon as possible; otherwise there’s the chance that they’re on a three game losing streak in all competitions coming into the next home match. That doesn’t sit well.

      Post a Reply
      • could easily be 4 straight defeats after new england, wouldn’t help fit that stadium.

        Post a Reply
      • Why the rush? Take your time getting that first home win.

        This is the problem Vanney is facing., losing has been the norm with him as manager of this team. Turning that culture around will not be a quick, sharp swing to the positive. It will be a long painful process and it may never happen. More likely Vanney will run out of time before he can effect the cultural change.

        Unfortunately, I think Sunday’s loss was both a symptom of the real problem with this team and also reinforced the problem with this team. His team is going through the motions waiting for the end to come.

        Post a Reply
  2. I agree that there is no reason to not try to win this tournament this year. There isn’t a ton of games to impact their playoff push, and then hopefully if they do make the playoffs this year, then next year they might have an extra goal to try to do well in the CCL.

    I think part of the reason these games aren’t well attended though is that it’s hard to sell tickets for a Wednesday evening. You probably just get the SSH crowd and a few other ticket sales, and that’s it. And then the CCL games are even worse because the SSH don’t have those games in their ticket package, so you don’t even get the automatic attendance from them.

    Maybe that’s why TFC doesn’t care – they don’t know how to sell tickets for those midweek games. But of course they can flood us with ads for stupid friendlies against EPL bench players…the masses will want to pay big money for a weeknight game against them!

    Funny how an organization that clearly loves to hype things doesn’t want to bother with hyping the Canadian Championship.

    Post a Reply
  3. well, can’t fault them for the lineup and the performance wasn’t terrible by any means, scored a couple of very nice goals, had quite a few chances, but once again the defence looked not good enough.
    the subs were strange, altidore was looking good, looking dangerous, very involved, can’t remember moore doing a thing after he came on, then after going behind again soon after, with ten or so minutes left, what does the student of the game do? throw hagglund on as a striker. real sophisticated. I get it, hagglund’s a set piece threat, but jesus that’s a desperate desperate move.

    No surprise of course to concede late to a former player

    then fireworks at the end! wow, that’s just all kinds of special.

    Post a Reply

Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *